Brand M
Brand Sticky

Request a Free Consultation 314-450-7849

Discrete. Effective. Aggressive.

Trial Attorneys

You Are Here:

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Criminal Defense
  4.  » High court rules for privacy in drug dog case

High court rules for privacy in drug dog case

On Behalf of | Apr 6, 2013 | Criminal Defense

The Supreme Court recently issued a ruling that could strike a blow to law enforcement agencies that rely heavily on drug-sniffing dogs for evidence in cases of drug charges. The court held 5-4 that an officer could not use a drug dog to sniff around the outside of a house where they suspect illegal activity.

The court held that a dog’s sniff constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment. In order to perform a search legally, officers must establish reasonable suspicion that a crime has been committed and get a search warrant.

In their decision the justices held that an officer outside a person’s house who does not have a search warrant is entitled to do as much as any other citizen. In most cases, that involves walking up and knocking on the door but nothing more. The court maintained that a person has a higher expectation of privacy in his or her home than in other places.

For example, the Supreme Court recently ruled in another case surrounding drug dogs. They held that a dog’s sniff could be used to gather evidence in a person’s stopped vehicle. The difference between these two decisions shows that the court values people’s privacy in their homes.

However, their justification for this decision hinged more on property rights than on privacy law. It is possible that future cases could help further clarify what is acceptable conduct by police officers and illuminate the court’s position on privacy in cases of drug charges with a questionable search.

Source: The FindLaw Blotter, “Drug Dogs Can’t Sniff Homes Without Warrant,” Andrew Lu, March 27, 2013

To learn more about defending against criminal charges in Missouri, please visit our website.


Notable Results

DWI Articles

FindLaw Network

Travis Noble is a graduate of the National College for DUI Defense at Harvard University, and he lectures at seminars nationwide on DWI/DUI topics. He is the lawyer whom other lawyers consult to defend their DWI clients. Most importantly, he has a track record of successfully defending some of the toughest DWI cases in Missouri and beyond.

Real Results

Winning Cases They Say Can't Be Won

Professional athletes, celebrities and high-profile clients

Doctors, lawyers, judges and police officers

Commercial drivers (CDL)

Clients facing jail or prison for a
felony DWI
Clients accused of
DWI accidents or
vehicular homicide